Disney, Universal, Midjourney: Who Gets to Protect Their Art?

Updated: Nov 1
AI Filmmaking & Copyright — Episode 4
Journeyman Entertainment | October 30, 2026

Who Gets to Protect Their Art? An AI-assisted illustration exploring the intersection of traditional creativity, generative AI, and copyright protection.
An Open Letter of Appreciation to Kelly Boesch
Her pioneering talent as a generative AI artist—combining her love of fashion, graphic artistry, and an almost supernatural imagination—has, in my opinion, placed her at the very top of this emerging art form.
Apparently, I'm not alone. One of her videos has attracted more than 23 million views on TikTok, while others have reached millions more. You don't achieve those numbers by producing unimaginative work.
For those unfamiliar with Kelly's work, I've included one of her videos below. And if the imagery isn't impressive enough, much of the accompanying music is also her creation. She develops the lyrical ideas, writes and revises lyrics, and directs the musical style using Suno, an AI music-generation platform, before bringing the music and visuals together in the edit.
It's a remarkable example of an artist using multiple AI tools to realize a singular creative vision.
But here's the question: With all that extraordinary imagery circulating across the digital universe, how does Kelly protect it? Can she protect it?
In a three-part interview with James Larkin at AImode.online, Kelly discussed her creative process, the extraordinary reach of her videos, and the challenges of having her work reposted without proper attribution or credit.
“What are you going to do, you can't fight 'em all”
Her words are a disheartening acknowledgment of the challenges facing individual artists in a digital world where creative work can travel around the globe in seconds.
Kelly has an open invitation to join me for an interview on the Journeyman Entertainment blog to discuss the challenges of protecting original AI artwork and where she sees copyright protection for AI-generated images headed in the near future. I'd love to have that conversation with her.
The Midjourney Copyright Lawsuit: Hollywood Goes to Court
Kelly's experience raises a question that reaches far beyond individual artists.
In June 2025, Disney and Universal filed a copyright infringement lawsuit against Midjourney, a generative AI platform used to create images and videos. Warner Bros. subsequently filed its own lawsuit, which was consolidated with the Disney–Universal case.
The studios allege that Midjourney used their copyrighted works without authorization and enables subscribers to generate recognizable protected characters, including those from Star Wars, Marvel, and other major entertainment franchises.
Midjourney disputes the claims. It argues that training AI systems on copyrighted material can qualify as fair use and has sought information about the studios' own AI development and production practices.
The studios maintain that their case concerns unauthorized exploitation of their intellectual property, regardless of how they may use AI themselves.
The dispute has moved into discovery, where the parties are fighting over evidence, training data, and the extent of Midjourney's legal responsibility.
None of this establishes that Midjourney has infringed copyright. Those are questions for the courts.
But the lawsuit raises an issue that goes well beyond Hollywood: Who gets to use the creative material that has shaped our culture—and under what circumstances?
Does Popular Culture Belong to the Universe?
Kelly Boesch's A Day in the Life of a Lonely Stormtrooper introduces another fascinating question.

Still from “A Day in the Life of a Lonely Stormtrooper” by Kelly Boesch. Reproduced for commentary on parody, fair use, and AI-assisted creativity.
When a fictional character becomes so deeply embedded in popular culture that virtually everyone recognizes it, does that character eventually belong, in some sense, to all of us?
Culturally, perhaps. Legally, it's another matter.
The Stormtrooper is unmistakably part of the Star Wars universe, whose distinctive characters and designs remain protected intellectual property. Lucasfilm Ltd, owned by the Walt Disney Company since 2012, holds the principal coprights and trademarks for the Star Wars characters and franchise.
American copyright law, however, recognizes fair use, which can sometimes permit the borrowing of copyrighted material for criticism, commentary, and parody.
There's an important distinction between parody, which comments on the original work, and satire, which may borrow familiar imagery to comment on something else. Both can raise fair-use arguments, but parody often has a stronger justification for using recognizable elements of the original.
So where does Kelly's lonely Stormtrooper fit? Is she commenting on the Star Wars universe itself, or borrowing one of its most recognizable characters to tell a different story about loneliness?
It's not a question we can answer simply by labeling the piece a parody. Fair use depends on the circumstances, including the purpose of the work, what was borrowed, and its potential effect on the market for the original.
And it demonstrates why protecting original creative work isn't always as simple as deciding who created the character first.
Two Sides of the Same Copyright Question
At first glance, Kelly Boesch and Disney might seem to occupy opposite ends of the creative universe.
One is an independent artist using generative AI to create extraordinary new imagery. The other is a global entertainment company seeking to protect decades of valuable intellectual property.
Yet both illustrate the importance of protecting creative work.
Disney and Universal have legitimate interests in defending their copyrighted characters, films, and other original material.
Kelly has an equally understandable interest in preventing others from appropriating her work without permission or attribution.
But the legal issues aren't identical.
Under current U.S. Copyright Office guidance, sufficiently creative human contributions to AI-assisted works may qualify for copyright protection. Purely AI-generated elements,
without the necessary human authorship, generally do not.
That distinction matters when an artist writes lyrics, develops characters, selects imagery, designs sequences, and edits a finished production. Some of those contributions may be protectable even when other elements were generated by AI.
Unauthorized reposting and failure to provide credit also raise questions of artistic ethics, platform practices, and potentially copyright law—but lack of attribution alone does not automatically establish infringement.
The challenge is determining where protected human expression begins and ends.
What the Midjourney Lawsuit Means for Independent Filmmakers
For filmmakers working with generative AI, the litigation raises practical questions that extend beyond the courtroom.
If an AI platform was trained using copyrighted material, what responsibility does its developer bear?
What happens when generated footage closely resembles a protected character?
And how much assurance does a commercial-use license actually provide?
A platform's permission to use generated material commercially is not necessarily a guarantee against third-party copyright claims. Nor does that permission automatically establish exclusive copyright ownership in every generated frame.
These distinctions matter when producers seek financing, distribution, and errors-and-omissions insurance.
There are also two separate questions at the heart of this debate: Was the material used to train the AI lawfully? And is the resulting work itself lawful and protectable?
A court's answer to one won't necessarily answer the other.
That's why filmmakers need to understand their platforms' terms, avoid unnecessary reliance on recognizable third-party properties, and document the human creative decisions behind their productions.
Protecting Creativity on Both Sides
The future of AI filmmaking should not force us to choose between protecting established intellectual property and recognizing original human creativity expressed through new technologies.
Disney and Universal deserve the protection afforded to their original copyrighted works. Midjourney deserves a fair opportunity to defend its technology and practices. And artists like Kelly Boesch deserve serious consideration of the human creativity embodied in their AI-assisted work.
These positions are not contradictory.
Ultimately, the question isn't whether traditional artists or AI artists deserve protection.
It's how copyright law can protect original human creativity without favoring one set of creative tools over another.
And that brings us back to Kelly Boesch. Her work reminds us that copyright is not simply a contest between Hollywood and Silicon Valley. It's also about individual artists whose imaginations give these technologies meaning.
Whether we're discussing original works created by Universal, creative expression produced through Midjourney, or the remarkable artistry of Kelly Boesch, the principle should remain the same: protect what is genuinely original and human-authored, while preserving room for new artists to build, comment, experiment, and create.
Coming Next — Episode 5: Who Actually Owns Your AI-Generated Footage? We'll examine the difference between commercial-use rights, copyright ownership, and exclusive control over AI-generated material.

This article is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. The litigation discussed remains subject to ongoing legal proceedings.





Comments